≡ Menu

“Militant Secularism Could Force Christians to Create New Subcultures”

An excerpt from my latest article, appearing at Lorehaven:


We often use the term “Christian ghetto” in a way intended to sound derogative. This phrase refers to an artistic subculture riddled with kitsch, propaganda, and second-rate content. Labels like “Christian fiction,” “Christian music,” and “Christian films” describe the lowlands of this ideological backwater.

However, the “Christian ghetto” term fails to reflect Christian consumers’ well-meaning approach to seek content that reflects their values and beliefs.

Yes, the Christian subculture may not always be technically on par with mainstream pop culture. But its makers share a legitimate, if not noble pursuit to provide its audience with alternative fare.

Nevertheless, we may have valid theological concerns at the root of our criticisms against such Christian subcultures. Jesus calls believers to be the salt of earth, to shine a light in the darkness. So how can we influence the world by withdrawing from it? In fact, the moral rot in many creative institutions could be due, in part, to Christians giving up on them.

This is why I’ve long applauded Christian artists engaging mainstream culture. It’s why I write my Reagan Moon paranormal thriller novels for the general market and no longer publish content labeled “Christian fiction.” It’s also why I’ve taught workshops for Christian authors about writing for the general market. It’s why I’ve blogged about “The Christian Crossover Novelist,” and it’s why I’ve asked, “Is Writing in the General Market LESS of a Ministry Than Writing for Christians?

But as much as I’m an advocate for Christian influencers in secular circles, I’ve lately found myself wondering if it isn’t in fact time for a new Christian subculture. Or, to put it another way, a tactical withdrawal.

So what caused me to change my mind? Let me explain.

You can read the entire article HERE.

{ 1 comment… add one }
  • Kessie January 25, 2021, 8:38 AM

    I can’t comment on SpecFaith because the comment form has no labels for where name/email go, haha! So I’m posting here.
    I’ve been drawing the same conclusions you come to here. There’s a crying need for the church to return to the Bible, for women to reject feminism and return to their husbands and children, for men to take up their role as the heads of their home. But who will teach them these things? I learned from Mary Pride’s The Way Home, but I don’t know if there is anyone writing anything similar in contemporary Christiandom. Women’s ministry seems to be hijacked by the likes of Jen Hatmaker and other heretics who tickle people’s ears. All I can think to do is to challenge other Christians to do the 1 hour prayer challenge. If we all prayed for 1 hour a day, it would change our lives, our families, our churches, and the world. But is there a faithful remnant left? Like Elijah, I cry out, is there any left who have not bent the knee to Baal?

Leave a Reply